Friday 31 March 2017

MPs' costs guard dog unintentionally posts private information on the web



Classified information about MPs' staff pay, working examples and occasions was coincidentally posted on the web for four hours by the Place of Hall costs guard dog.

The Autonomous Parliamentary Norms Expert (Ipsa) said it was keeping in touch with all MPs and their staff influenced to apologize for the misery brought on.

A representative said the guard dog was cautioned to the "genuine information rupture" by a MP's individual from staff after the record was transferred in mistake on an old site on Thursday night.

It included private individual data about the names of MPs' staff, compensations, rewards, working examples and occasion qualifications.

In a letter to MPs, Marcial Boo, the CEO of Ipsa, said the report was brought down inside a hour of it getting to be noticeably mindful of the issue."We consider data security important and the wellbeing and security of MPs and their staff is a need," he said.

"An examination is as of now under way and we have advised the data chief. We will compose straightforwardly to those influenced. I truly apologize to you for the misery this has caused."He said no data identifying with the security of the people influenced had been made open.

"No locations, no financial balance points of interest, no telephone numbers, and no National Protection numbers were revealed. In any case, we perceive this was still to a great degree delicate individual data," Boo included.

Ipsa, which was set up to manage a more tightly costs administration after the embarrassment of 2009, has been disliked with MPs since its origin, with grievances generally installments and an excessively confounded PC framework.

Sturgeon demanded the Scottish government would play "a full and valuable part in securing" the most ideal Brexit bargain for the UK, despite the fact that Scottish voters did not vote last June to leave the EU.

That gambled negating notices from her representativehttp://groceryshoppingapp.blogszino.com/grocery-shopping-app-iphone-android-contemporary-photography/ on Thursday that Sturgeon could decline to bolster the Brexit enactment in the event that she trusted Westminster was neglecting to pass on the correct EU forces to Holyrood.

In spite of offering to defer the vote if important, Sturgeon demanded that discussions on passing those forces to Scotland under a supposed area 30 request ought to begin as quickly as time permits. It ought to be "a moderately clear process" given both governments had experienced it five years prior to set up the 2014 submission.

Refering to the Holyrood vote on Tuesday and her pronouncement vow to arrange a choice if the UK left the EU without wanting to, Sturgeon revealed to May she now had a reasonable command to seek after a choice in view of Scottish conventions of "prominent power".

Bringing down Road affirmed May would not consent to those discussions before Brexit. It is out of line to the general population of Scotland to request that they settle on a vital choice without the important data about our future association with Europe, or what an autonomous Scotland would resemble," a representative said.

Foreseeing May would again decline to concur, Sturgeon cautioned she would set out another methodology to secure that choice after the Easter occasions – notwithstanding the UK government's restriction.

"It is my firm view that the order of the Scottish parliament must be regarded and advanced. The question is not if, but rather how," Sturgeon composed.

Be that as it may, rehashed supposition surveys indicate just around 35% of voters concur with her claim a submission before Brexit is essential. Bolster for autonomy is static at around 45%, with a few surveys proposing it is closer half.

In a short video communicate on the Scottish government's Twitter channel, the primary priest took a mollifying tone by asking yes and no voters to concur there was a reasonable good case for the choice forces to be given to Holyrood, regardless of the possibility that they didn't back autonomy.

Kezia Dugdale, the Scottish Work pioneer, said Sturgeon's mission for the submission would frighten voters and was not in view of mainstream sway. "There is positively no proof that another divisive submission is the will of the general population of Scotland," she said.

"Holding another choice on leaving the UK is the wrong thing to accomplish for Scotland's economy, particularly when there is so much monetary vulnerability from the Tories' foolhardy arrangements for a hard Brexit."

My significant other, Marilyn McCord Adams, who has passed on of growth matured 73, was the primary lady, and the main American, to hold the regius residency of heavenliness at Oxford.

In that limit, amid the years 2004-09, and as a delegate to the General Synod of the Congregation of Britain, she was broadly known for her strong safeguard of steadfast same-sex organizations as genuine articulations of Christian love.

Her feelings regarding that matter were framed in Los Angeles in the 1980s. While showing logic at UCLA (the College of California at Los Angeles), and distributing a conclusive two-volume investigation of the logic of William Ockham, Marilyn was likewise get ready for appointment as a cleric in the Episcopal church.

As a component of that procedure she was aiding service at a congregation in Hollywood, where gay men, in the principal ghastly years of the Guides emergency, were looking for profound support. She was profoundly moved by their need, and no less by the profundity of their affection and dependability towards each other.

Amid those years, additionally, she turned her interests increasingly towards Christian philosophy and religious service. She never surrendered the dedication to philosophical thinking shaped amid her times of learn at the College of Illinois in Urbana (BA 1964) and Cornell College (PhD 1967). In any case, the point that most held her, and most propelled her scholarly work through whatever is left of her life was the religious issue of malevolence.

She built up a particular approach that majorly affected examination of that issue. In Appalling Indecencies and the Decency of God (2000), she doesn't attempt to answer the question, "Why did God allow every one of the shades of malice that we think about?" Rather she inquires.

"What can God do to make our reality an extraordinary decent to us, without trivializing the frightful wrongs that we think about?" And she gives an answer as far as kinship offered by God, which she found in the account of Jesus, and furthermore observed reverberated in the lives of gay individuals adoring each other notwithstanding Helps.

Conceived in a suburb of Chicago, to William McCord, a pipeline designer, and his significant other, Wilmah (nee Dark colored), a teacher, Marilyn experienced childhood in residential communities in rustic east-focal Illinois.

In any case, she cherished college towns and expansive urban communities. A large portion of her previous understudies and their families frame the biggest piece of a dedicated more distant family that survives her.

The driver of a container lorry which smashed in Glasgow, killing six individuals, has conceded jeopardizing people in general only nine months after the disaster by driving in spite of having had his permit denied for medicinal reasons.

Harry Clarke, 60, was marked "indefensible" as he was restricted from the streets for a long time in the wake of conceding "suspiciously and neglectfully" driving an auto to the risk of people in general on 20 September 2015.He was sentenced at Glasgow sheriff court on Friday subsequent to confessing to the offense at a hearing a month ago.

Clarke was given a group payback arrange with a 12-month supervisionhttps://www.scout.org/user/687806/about prerequisite and 150 hours' unpaid work. He should wear an electronic tag under a confinement of freedom request which implies he can't leave his home in the vicinity of 7pm and 7am.

Clarke had conceded driving in September 2015 in the learning he had endured lost awareness on 22 December 2014 while in the driver's seat of a moving deny lorry in Glasgow downtown area, bringing about six passings and leaving 15 individuals harmed.

Sheriff Martin Jones, sentencing, revealed to Clarke he passed the "authority limit" yet that he was legitimately kept from imprisoning him since he was a first guilty party.

He stated: "You should comprehend that the choice you made to drive your vehicle out and about, notwithstanding for a short separation, was one which was completely flighty and indefensible.

"It was profoundly chargeable and put the wellbeing of the general population at hazard. That was a hazard which had been completely disclosed to you and prompted the denial of your driving permit on restorative grounds.

"You more likely than not been intensely mindful of the conceivable outcomes of you enduring lost cognizance while driving after the sad results emerging from the episode on 22 December 2014."

Clarke knew he had endured lost cognizance or scene of modified mindfulness while in the driver's seat of a stationary transport on 7 April 2010.

The charge expressed that he knew, or should have known, that he was unfit to drive, and that there was a hazard he may lose cognizance or endure a scene of modified mindfulness while driving.

He was not arraigned over the container lorry crash, with the Crown Office demanding there was inadequate confirmation to raise criminal procedures.

Jack and Lorraine Sweeney, 68 and 69, and their granddaughter Erin McQuade, 18, Stephenie Tait, 29, Jacqueline Morton, 51, and Gillian Ewing, 52, passed on in the occurrence.

A deadly mishap request decided that the crash may have been stayed away from if Clarke had come clean about his therapeutic history. His permit was repudiated inconclusively on restorative grounds on 27 June 2015.

At the hearing a month ago, senior monetary depute Martin Allan told the court that neighbors called the police in the wake of seeing Clarke driving in Baillieston, Glasgow, on 20 September 2015.

He stated: "Both were suspicious about his capacity to drive as a result of the media scope and they did some examination on the web and found that his permit had been renounced on therapeutic grounds."

Police went to Clarke's home on 22 September and he was advised and charged. The court heard that he told police: "I have never been out on an open street.

Ofsted has raised the possibility of utilizing Facebook and Twitter presents on break down how schools are performing.

The schools guard dog said it was investigating "the likelihood of utilizing close constant information and data from web-based social networking and different sources to anticipate and avoid decrease in school execution".

The association said the recurrence and substance of web-based social networking posts about a specific school could help it choose whether an overseer ought to visit sooner

Schools positioned "extraordinary" don't have routine investigations unless there are worries that norms might slip, while "great" schools have short examinations at regular intervals.

Stamp Orchison, the overseeing executive of 9ine Counseling, which exhorts schools on everything from protecting to cybersecurity, said it appeared to be likely the activity would include assembling constant information about what individuals were saying in regards to individual schools.

He said it could be helpful as far as supporting work that Ofsted as of now does investigating parental impression of their youngsters' schools, however it was likewise conceivably unsafe.

"Individuals can put fake data about schools, they can make false allegations about schools," Orchison stated, refering to the case of a displeased understudy or parent posting fake assertions about an instructor.

"My worry would be how would you approve the data that it gives you, how would you discount fake data and what weighting do you join to the data that you have? It could be useful [for discovering perceptions] however in the event that you begin utilizing it in a more reformatory manner it could be very hazardous."

A 2015 overview by the Relationship of Instructors and Speakers, which as of late voted to converge with the National Union of Educators, found that more than one in five school staff have had a false affirmation made against them by a student.

Ofsted said it was not right now assembling data from web-based social networking and that any work here would be kept to open online discussions, however educators said they were concerned.

Russell Side interest, the general secretary of the school pioneers' union NAHT, stated: "For an administration office to utilize web-based social networking posts as information would raise doubt about its dedication to confirm based practice.

"Online networking contains unconfirmed prattle, and ought not be judged a dependable wellspring of data. We know it is a place where individuals go to express their dissatisfactions, not give measured and valuable criticism."

An Ofsted representative stated: "Like any controller, we are continually taking a gander at how we can enhance our observing of norms in schools and to distinguish where there might be worries about youngsters' security or the nature of training they are accepting.

"Say that we don't as of now order data from online networking channels. Any work that we may do around there later on would obviously be kept to open gatherings and would be for the sole motivation behind choosing whether to present a review in specific cases."

England's exchanging position with whatever remains of the world enhanced particularly in the last three months of 2016, boosting trusts that the pound's sharp fall since the Brexit vote can help the economy turn out to be less dependent on household spending.

As sterling's fall made UK products more aggressive on abroad markets and supported fares, there was a huge narrowing in the UK's present record deficiency, the most recent ONS development figures appeared. Financial analysts said the rebalancing towards more fares would counterbalance a few yet not the greater part of the stoppage in purchaser spending expected for this present year as wages are pressed.

"While the drop in the pound is plainly boosting expansion, it is additionally making them counterbalance positive effects through achieving a hotly anticipated rebalancing of the economy towards the outside part," said Paul Hollingsworth at the consultancy Capital Financial aspects.

The present record deficiency mirrors England's exchange crevice with whatever remains of the world and the setback between cash paid out by the UK and cash coming in. In the final quarter of 2016 it more than split to £12bn from £25.7bn in the third. It likened to 2.4% of Gross domestic product, the least level since the second quarter of 2011.

The ONS said the change was mostly because of the sharp narrowing of the exchange shortfall, or the hole amongst fares and imports, which thus was supported by the fall in the pound since the EU choice.

Before a year ago's submission on EU enrollment, the Bank of Britain had highlighted England's record current record crevice and noticed that the UK depends on remote financial specialists to finance the deficiency.

The Bank's senator, Check Carney, communicated worry that in case of a vote to leave the EU, outside financial specialists would turn out to be more apprehensive about purchasing or holding UK resources.

Financial experts said those feelings of trepidation had not left with the most recent figures and the pound stayed helpless against news of another augmenting in the present record.

"The load of abroad's financial specialists resources in the UK compares to a huge 547% of yearly Gross domestic product. Sterling would deteriorate encourage if just a little extent of these speculators took off," said Samuel Tombs at the consultancy Pantheon Macroeconomics. "Signs that the UK is setting out toward a hard Brexit could be a trigger for such a fire deal."

Howard Toxophilite, a financial specialist at consultancy IHS Markit, said the smaller shortfall was welcome news for the UK economy. He too was careful about the nation's future exchange execution and capacity to draw in abroad financial specialists however said the present record deficiency ought to be lower over the coming quarters.

"Sterling's checked debilitating seems, by all accounts, to be progressively sustaining through to lift sends out, aided by current not too bad worldwide request. Moreover, the exchange deficiency ought to be constrained by softening residential request restricting imports," said Toxophilite.

Donald Tusk's letter setting the terms for arranging the UK's takeoff from the EU was the minute when Theresa May's talk slammed into reality, as indicated by a series of government officials who have been cautioning against a hard Brexit.

Chris Leslie, the previous shadow chancellor, said the letter by the leader of the European board denoted the development of "the chilly, hard substances of present day global exchange and tact after all the conversing with ourselves throughout the previous nine months".

He said a portion of the stressing angles were "precluding remaining in the single market, and the no-go on part by-area bargains and the restriction on attempting to go round the commission to various heads of state is a really firm message, practically like they will police it".

Tim Farron, the Liberal Democrats' pioneer, whose gathering is driving the political battle against Brexit, stated: "The terms are clear: no division by-part bargains, no respective arrangements and no new exchange bargain until the withdrawal terms are concurred. This leaves most likely David Davis' remarks about uncommon courses of action for the auto business or money related area are useless."

Various Traditionalists were likewise worried about the unexpectedhttps://www.apsense.com/user/shopcluesapp specify of Gibraltar in the draft rules, clarifying that any future course of action would not make a difference to the stone unless concurred by both Spain and England.

Weave Neill, a Tory MP and previous clergyman, stated: "It is the kind of thing you may expect as far as their begin position. Be that as it may, just demonstrates the supposed hard Brexiteers who thought this may be basic are in for a truly extreme rude awakening."

Neill approached the executive to "make it clear from the earliest starting point that the sway of Gibraltar is not on the table". He stated: "Gibraltar has companions in the UK parliament who will make it liberally obvious that there can't be any exchanging of sway and Gibraltar can't be inadvertent blow-back or utilized as a negotiating advantage," calling attention to it would not be to Spain's greatest advantage to disappoint frictionless exchange.

Andrew Rosindell, the Preservationist bad habit seat of the all-party parliamentary gathering for Gibraltar, said "there can be no assention" with Gibraltar on the table.

"English individuals should and will stand together," he said. "We can't be harassed by Spain. Any assention must apply similarly to the entire English family and that incorporates Gibraltar. There can be no bargain on this."

Be that as it may, No 10 and numerous Brexit campaigners were generally cheery about the recommendations from Tusk, proposing the conditions could have been much more terrible.

Inside Bringing down Road, the state of mind was generally casual about the reaction to May's opening gambit, with senior figures saying there were "no curve balls truly" and that the general tone was great.

The reaction from Jeremy Corbyn, the Work pioneer, was likewise quiet, respecting Tusk's choice to "mollify the EU's resistance to chats on exchange occurring before the terms of withdrawal are concurred".

Business bunches had all the earmarks of being saving judgment, with the CBI saying there were early signs transactions would head down the correct way yet the gathering needed to see conviction on the fate of EU natives in weeks not months.

"Discourses on new exchanging game plans ought to run as an inseparable unit with arranging the UK's exit from the EU. We need this to occur at the earliest opportunity, which is the reason the following six months are pivotal," said Josh Hardie, CBI executive general.

In any case, driving figures in the Brexit crusade were sure the letter demonstrated the EU had moved to a place where it was quick to make an arrangement. "This exhibits they are significantly more adaptable about this than was initially assumed and reveals to us that Germany is winding up noticeably considerably more persuasive," said Iain Duncan Smith, the previous bureau serve.

"So it now seems as though they are making the inquiry, 'how would we achieve an understanding?' as opposed to, 'how would we rebuff them?' That is the shift.

"It's awesome to see Tusk veto rebuffing the UK for leaving, and concur exchange arrangements ought to start before the article 50 process is finished," he said. "Be that as it may, despite the fact that he's set a systematic and helpful tone, Brussels will even now arrange hard.

That is the reason they're requesting €60bn [£51bn] provision for the separation," he said. "We shouldn't give their weight a chance to get to us; both sides have a great deal to pick up from an effective arrangement, yet a gigantic missed open door in the event that it doesn't occur as well."

The most hardline of Brexiters utilized a portion of the letter's hardest requests – on a budgetary settlement and the planning – to contend that the UK ought to be set up to leave without an arrangement.

"By putting the separation settlement to start with, the EU are breaking their legitimate commitments under article 50," said Richard Tice, co-seat of the Leave Implies Leave battle.

"In the event that the EU decline to conform to law amid transactions, England ought to leave the table until Brussels go to their senses."A nation specialist has uncovered that he has been working two jobs for as long as 30 years as a character in the Toxophilite.

In a story to coordinate the frequently unrealistic plotlines of the radio cleanser's anecdotal town of Ambridge, Dr Graham Blockey denoted his retirement as a GP in Surrey by trip himself as the voice behind the character Robert Snell.

Blockey said he assumed the part of the put-upon spouse to Lynda Snell amid his time off at ends of the week and on Thursday evenings. Some of his patients in Leith Slope town knew about their specialist's actor misuses, yet he said he kept the part mystery from the vast majority of them because of a paranoid fear of losing their regard.

"I wasn't quick to advance it. In the event that I blew my own particular trumpet they may lose confidence and I may have lost a touch of that specialist," Blockey said. "There is a statistic that has a tendency to tune in to the Toxophilite and a great deal of my patients are in that statistic."

In quieting tones well-known to Toxophilite audience members, Blockey said he tried out for the piece of another specialist in the show in 1986. He was told his voice did not sufficiently sound like a specialist and was offered the piece of Robert Snell.

"Perhaps the desire of a nation specialist was diverse then," he said.Blockey qualified as a specialist in 1979, and swung back to solution subsequent to attempting to discover standard work as an on-screen character.

"I was a full-time on-screen character in my 20s, yet then I had children and I was doing things like playing a tomato in emulate and I began to think, 'hold tight a moment, maybe solution is additionally satisfying'," he said.

Blockey talked about the trouble of joining his low maintenance radio employment with his full-time part as an accomplice at the surgery."I would do the Toxophilite at ends of the week and my Thursday evenings off when I could get up to Birmingham. Furthermore, in the event that they needed a noteworthy storyline I would book seven days' leave, the length of my medicinal accomplices concurred."

Blockey's opportunity limitations help to clarify his more restricted appearances on the Bowmen contrasted and the more noticeable part of his anecdotal spouse Lynda, who as inn assistant and beginner shows manager is an Ambridge stalwart.

"He's not a major part, but rather he's critical on the grounds that he's wedded to this real character Lynda, who is very unpredictable and a town meddler. So he keeps her grounded, and is there every now and then. On the off chance that he was a noteworthy character they would have recast, yet to their awesome acknowledge they stuck for me throughout the years."

Asked what exhortation Lynda Snell would give a disappointed performer playing a tomato, Blockey stated: "She would instruct them to acknowledge the expert need and venture control and their stagecraft."

Scenes between the two have frequently included Lynda conversing with Robert without finding a solution. "They would compose around my accessibility, it's an old radio trap," Blockey said.

In any case, now that he has resigned as a GP, Blockey, 61, arrangements to invest more energy acting. Asked whether he would have a more noticeable part in the Toxophilite he said he trusted in this way, yet had been given no indications from the makers.

Blockey said he was anticipating retirement as a GP."I will miss the patients, however I won't miss the investigation. The consistence with directions is difficult and getting all the more along these lines, and the inclination that you need to legitimize your choices all the time requires some serious energy, and incurs significant injury. It's a weight."

A 23-year-old vagrant has been accused of the murder of a lady and her 13-year-old child together with the endeavored murder of the young person's dad.

West Midlands police said on Friday they had charged Aaron Grain, of no settled habitation, the assaults at a family home in Stourbridge, West Midlands. Grain will show up before Birmingham justices on Saturday morning.

Companions and neighbors have said the Wilkinson family encouraged a vagranthttp://www.misterpoll.com/users/406572 subsequent to running over him while he was asking in a road.

Tracey Wilkinson, 50, and her child Penetrate kicked the bucket of cut wounds after an episode at their vast redbrick home on a verdant path on Thursday morning.

Wilkinson's better half, Subside, was gravely harmed and stays in doctor's facility, where his condition is steady. The family likewise have a little girl, Lydia, who was away at Bristol College.

A man was captured not long after the occurrence after a Land Meanderer supposedly taken from the Wilkinsons' home crushed into a divider adjacent.

As police affirmed that a man had been charged over the occurrences, many schoolfriends of Pierce, who went to the adjacent Redhill school, landed at the cordon close to the family home to offer their regards.

Some laid blossoms; others basically stood and gazed at the police tent set up outside their companion's home. A couple of the young ladies embraced.

In an announcement Stephen Dunster, the headteacher of Redhill school, stated: "Puncture was a faithful, mindful and reliable student, will's identity unfortunately missed by all individuals from our school group.

He generally met everybody with a grin and was a kind and mindful youthful man."He was enthusiastic about his football group, West Bromwich Albion, and was committed to his pet greyhound canine.

"He was a cherishing child and sibling. Our musings and supplications stay with his family, specifically his dad Subside and his sister Lydia. Understudies and staff are in school today and are being offered proficient help and directing.

We might want to thank everybody in the group for their offers of support and condolences."During the day wellwishers had conveyed tributes and one individual left a West Bromwich Albion scarf at the cordon.

Tracey Parbery, the seat of the Lobby Green Resigned Greyhound Trust, set a toy greyhound at the scene. The Wilkinsons had rehomed a resigned greyhound called Mandy, which was driven far from the house on Thursday.

She stated: "They had upheld us from numerous points of view since they had the puppy and they were outstanding to our volunteers, who are crushed. They were a beautiful family, extremely honest to goodness and everyone who met them said what pleasant youngsters they had."

A family companion said they had taken in a vagrant around a year back. He stated: "It raised and they welcomed him round to their home for suppers. They would give him a chance to do odd occupations in the garden and around the house for cash and sustenance. They were an exquisite family."

A card departed at the scene read: "I can't trust your demonstration of consideration has finished this way."Tory councilor Colin Elcock said of the Wilkinsons: "They were an exquisite couple. Subside was a representative, and used to make a trip a ton to the USA and Europe with his occupation, yet both he and Tracey helped me convey handouts."

One neighbor, who would not like to be named, said she had picked blossoms from her own particular garden in light of the fact that Tracey Wilkinson was continually discussing nation blooms.

She stated: "Everybody is as yet paralyzed here and I trust we find a few solutions since we can't make sense of what has happened."

Neighbor Colin Giles, 82, stated: "Just as of late Subside saw me attempting to clean my drive and stated: 'That is no real way to do it' and gave me a power apparatus to stream shower it. They were a beautiful couple."

Talking outside the family home on Thursday, Supt Lee Kendrick of West Midlands police stated: "What has unfurled here is awful and disastrous. Police and emergency vehicle were gone up against with a dreadful scene: a man, lady and kid all with intense cut wounds. The lady and kid were found in the house and the man in the garden.

"Appallingly, there was nothing that should be possible to spare the lady, and her child later kicked the bucket in doctor's facility from his wounds."

An after death and formal recognizable proof will occur on Monday.

A police representative stated: "A man has been accused of the murder of a Stourbridge mother and her child in Norton yesterday and the endeavored murder of the lady's significant other.

"Aaron Grain, of no settled address, will show up before Birmingham officers tomorrow (Saturday 1 April) to face charges of the murder of 50-year-old Tracey Wilkinson and her child, 13-year-old Pierce.

"The 23-year-old is likewise accused of the endeavored murder of 47-year-old Dwindle Wilkinson who stays in a steady condition in doctor's facility.

"The couple and their child were found with wound wounds at their home in Greyhound Path soon after 8am yesterday morning. An after death examination and formal distinguishing proof will occur on Monday (3 April)."

The crush on family spending plans will fix this end of the week as a scope of value ascends, from solution expenses to vitality charges, produce results.

Gathering charge bills, broadband costs, cell phone charges and even the cost of a postage stamp are going up this end of the week.

The phantomhttp://nitro-nitf.sourceforge.net/wikka.php?wakka=SwaroopAhmed of expansion has come back to stalk the UK economy, as the post-choice droop in the pound has driven up the cost of imported merchandise from petroleum to tea, angle and cell phones.

Staple expansion multiplied a month ago to 1.4%. The ascent in sustenance costs finished a keep running of false.

No comments:

Post a Comment